Public School Magazine, February 1902


THE struggle between Carter’s cat and Carter’s cat’s conscience was short, and ended in the hollowest of victories for the former. The conscience really had no sort of chance from the beginning. It was weak by nature and flabby from long want of exercise, while the cat was in excellent training, and was, moreover, backed up by a strong temptation. It pocketed the stakes, which consisted of most of the contents of a tin of sardines, and left unostentatiously by the window. When Smith came in after football, and found the remains, he was surprised, and even pained. When Montgomery entered soon afterwards, he questioned him on the subject.

“I say, have you been having a sort of preliminary canter with the banquet?”

“No,” said Montgomery. “Why?”

“Somebody has,” said Smith, exhibiting the empty tin. “Doesn’t seem to have had such a bad appetite, either.”

“This reminds me of the story of the great bear, the medium bear and the little ditto,” observed Montgomery, who was always apt at an analogy. “You may remember that when the great bear found his porridge tampered with, he—”

At this point Shawyer entered. He had been bidden to the feast, and was feeling ready for it.

“Hullo, tea ready?” he asked.

Smith displayed the sardine tin in much the same manner as the conjurer shows a pack of cards when he entreats you to choose one, and remember the number.

“You haven’t finished already, surely? Why it’s only just five.”

“We haven’t even begun,” said Smith. “That’s just the difficulty. The question is, who has been on the raid in here?”

“No human being has done this horrid thing,” said Montgomery. He always liked to introduce a Holmes-Watsonian touch into the conversation. “In the first place, the door was locked, wasn’t it, Smith?”

“By jove, so it was. Then how on earth—?”

“Through the window, of course. The cat, equally of course. I should like a private word with that cat.”

“I suppose it must have been.”

“Of course it was. Apart from the merely circumstantial evidence, which is strong enough to hang it off its own bat, we have absolute proof of its guilt. Just cast your eye over that butter. You follow me, Watson?”

The butter was submitted to inspection. In the very centre of it there was a footprint.

I traced his little footprints in the butter,” said Montgomery. “Now, is that the mark of a human foot?”

The jury brought in a unanimous verdict of guilty against the missing animal, and over a sorrowful cup of tea, eked out with bread and jam—butter appeared to be unpopular—discussed the matter in all its bearings. The cat had not been an inmate of Carter’s House for a very long time, and up till now what depredations it had committed had been confined to the official larder. Now, however, it had evidently got its hand in, and was about to commence operations upon a more extensive scale. The Tabby Terror had begun. Where would it end? The general opinion was that something would have to be done about it. No one seemed to know exactly what to do. Montgomery spoke darkly of bricks, bits of string, and horse-ponds. Smith rolled the word “rat-poison” luxuriously round his tongue. Shawyer, who was something of an expert on the range, babbled of air-guns.

At tea on the following evening the first really serious engagement of the campaign took place. The cat strolled into the tearoom in the patronising way characteristic of his kind, but was heavily shelled with lump-sugar, and beat a rapid retreat. That was the signal for the outbreak of serious hostilities. From that moment its paw was against every man, and the tale of the things it stole is too terrible to relate in detail. It scored all along the line. Like Death in the poem, it knocked at the doors of the highest and the lowest alike. Or rather, it did not exactly knock. It came in without knocking. The palace of the Prefect and the hovel of the fag suffered equally. Trentham, the Head of the House, lost sausages to an incredible amount one evening, and the next day Ripton, of the Lower Third, was robbed of his one ewe lamb in the shape of half a tin of anchovy paste. Panic reigned.

It was after this matter of the sausages that a luminous idea occurred to Trentham. He had been laid up with a slight football accident, and his family, reading between the lines of his written statement that he “had got crocked at footer, nothing much, only (rather a nuisance) might do him out of the House matches” a notification of mortal injuries, and seeming to hear a death-rattle through the words “felt rather chippy yesterday,” had come down en masse to investigate. En masse, that is to say, with the exception of his father, who said he was too busy, but felt sure that it was nothing serious. (“Why, when I was a boy, my dear, I used to think nothing of an occasional tumble. There’s nothing the matter with Dick. Why, etc., etc.).

Trentham’s sister, Dorothy, was his first visitor.

“I say, Doll,” said he, when he had satisfied her on the subject of his health, “would you like to do me a good turn?”

She intimated that she would be delighted, and asked for details.

Buy the beak’s cat,” hissed Trentham, in a hoarse whisper.

“Dick, it was your leg that you hurt, wasn’t it? Not—not your head?” she replied. “I mean—”

“No, I really mean it. Why can’t you? It’s a perfectly simple thing to do.”

“But what is a beak? and why should I buy it’s cat?”

“A beak’s a master. Surely you know that. You see, Carter’s got a cat lately, and the beast strolls in and raids the studies. Got round over half a pound of prime sausages in here the other night, and he’s always bagging things everywhere. You’d be doing everyone a kindness if you would take him on. He’ll get lynched some day if you don’t. Besides you want a cat for your new house, surely. Keep down the mice, and that sort of thing, you know. This animal’s a demon for mice.” This was a telling argument. Trentham’s sister had lately been married, and she certainly had had some idea of investing in a cat to adorn her home. “As for beetles,” continued the invalid, pushing home his advantage, “they simply daren’t come out of their lairs for fear of him.”

“If he eats beetles,” objected Dorothy, “he can’t have a very good coat.”

“He doesn’t eat them. Just squashes them you know, like a policeman. He’s a decent enough beast as far as looks go.’’

“But if he steals things—”

“No, don’t you see, he only does that here, because the Carters don’t interfere with him and don’t let us do anything to him. He won’t try that sort of thing on with you. If he does, get somebody to hit him over the head with a boot-jack or something. He’ll soon drop it then. You might as well, you know. The House ’ll simply black your boots if you do.”

“I don’t want my boots blacked at all. They’re brown, you see. But would Mr. Carter let me have the cat?”

“Try him anyhow. Pitch it fairly warm, you know. Only cat you ever loved, and that sort of thing.”

“Very well. I’ll try.”

“Thanks, awfully. And, I say, you might just look in here on your way out and report.”

Mrs. James Williamson, née Miss Dorothy Trentham, made her way dutifully to the Merevales’ part of the House. Mrs. Carter had expressed a hope that she would have a cup of tea before catching her train. With tea it is usual to have milk, and with milk it is usual, if there is a cat in the house, to have feline society. Captain Kettle, which was the name thought suitable to this cat by his godfathers and godmothers, was on hand early. As he stood there pawing the mat impatiently and mewing in a minor key, Mrs. Williamson felt that here was the cat for her. He certainly was good to look upon. His black heart was hidden by a sleek coat of tabby fur, which rendered stroking a luxury. His scheming brain was out of sight in a shapely head.

“Oh, what a lovely cat!” said Mrs. Williamson.

“Yes, isn’t he,” agreed Mrs. Carter. “We are very proud of him.”

“Such a beautiful coat!”

“And such a sweet purr!”

“He looks so intelligent. Has he any tricks?”

“Had he any tricks! Why, Mrs. Williamson, he could do everything except speak. Captain Kettle, you bad boy, come here and die for your country. Puss, puss.”

Captain Kettle came at last reluctantly, died for his country in record time, and flashed back again to the saucer. He had an important appointment. Sorry to appear rude and all that sort of thing, don’t you know, but he had to see a cat about a mouse.

“Well?” said Trentham, when his sister looked in upon him an hour later.

“Oh, Dick, its the nicest cat I ever saw. I shall never be happy if I don’t get it.”

“Have you bought it?” asked the practical Trentham.

“My dear Dick, I couldn’t. We couldn’t bargain about a cat during tea. Why, I never met Mrs. Carter before this afternoon.”

“No, I suppose not,” admitted Trentham, gloomily. “Anyhow, look here, if anything turns up to make the beak want to get rid of it, I’ll tell him you’re dead nuts on it. See?”

For a fortnight after this episode matters went on as before. Mrs. Williamson departed, thinking regretfully of the cat she had left behind her.

Captain Kettle died for his country with moderate regularity, and on one occasion, when he attempted to extract some milk from the very centre of a fags’ tea-party, almost died for another reason. Then the end came suddenly.

Trentham had been invited to supper one Sunday by Mr. Carter. When he arrived it became apparent to him that the atmosphere was one of subdued gloom. At first he could not understand this, but soon the reason was made clear. Captain Kettle had, in the expressive language of the man in the street, been and gone and done it. He had been left alone that evening in the drawing-room, while the House was at church, and his eye, roaming restlessly about in search of evil to perform, had lighted upon a cage. In that cage was a special sort of canary, in its own line as accomplished an artiste as Captain Kettle himself. It sang with taste and feeling, and made itself generally agreeable in a number of little ways. But to Captain Kettle it was merely a bird. One of the poets sings of an acquaintance of his who was so constituted that “a primrose by the river’s brim a simple primrose was to him, and it was nothing more.” Just so with Captain Kettle. He was not the cat to make nice distinctions between birds. Like the cat in another poem, he only knew they made him light and salutary meals. So with the exercise of considerable ingenuity he extracted that canary from its cage and ate it. He was now in disgrace.

“We shall have to get rid of him,” said Mr. Carter.

“I am afraid so,” said Mrs. Carter.

“If you weren’t thinking of giving him to anyone in particular, sir,” said Trentham, “my sister would be awfully glad to take him, I know. She was very keen on him when she came to see me.”

“That’s excellent,” said Carter. “I was afraid we should have to send him to a home somewhere.”

“I suppose we can’t keep him after all?” suggested Mrs. Carter.

Trentham waited in suspense.

“No,” said Carter, decidedly. “I think not.” So Captain Kettle went, and the House knew him no more, and The Tabby Terror was at an end.



Printed unsigned in Public School Magazine; entered by Wodehouse in Money Received for Literary Work. When this story was collected in Tales of St. Austin’s, Carter was renamed Prater, and the story title appeared in quotation marks.



a primrose by the river’s brim a simple primrose was to him: William Wordsworth’s ‘Peter Bell’

The one-legged Captain Kettle K.C.B. was the creation of author Cutcliffe Hyne, remembered as the author of ‘The Lost Continent: The Story of Atlantis.’ From 1895 to 1901, Pearson’s ran his series of swashbuckling stories featuring the adventurer Captain Kettle. In March 1903, Hyne announced he was ending the series, causing consternation to his many fans.


John Dawson


No human being has done this horrid thing: Reminiscent of The Sign of the Four, ch. VI:

“Holmes,” I said, in a whisper, “a child has done this horrid thing.”

Lord Uffenham’s accusation about “those kids at the Nook” in Something Fishy, ch. 8, is also compared to this sentence of Dr. Watson’s.

Death in the poem: Probably Horace’s ode “To Sestius” (Book I:4): “Death comes alike to all—to the monarch’s lordly hall, Or the hovel of the beggar...” (tr. Theodore Martin)

cats and beetles: also discussed in Ch. 24 of Psmith, Journalist


Neil Midkiff